perspectives

PR professionals often tell me they don’t understand why a pitch they believe is genuinely newsworthy didn’t get picked up.

 

The reality is that the value of any pitch isn’t absolute. It’s relative to a ton of other factors, many of which have nothing to do with the pitch itself.

​

Consider this:

​

If I offered you $1 million or $10,000, which would you choose?

​

I’m guessing you’d take the million bucks.

​

But what if I offered you $10,000 or $10 instead?

​

The value of that $10,000 didn’t change. The context did.

​

That’s how journalists evaluate story ideas.

​

Every day, reporters and editors weigh pitches not only against each other, but against enterprise reporting ideas, breaking developments, scheduled events and stories their competitors are covering. They’re making choices about what deserves limited available time and attention.

 

And getting a reporter interested is only one part of the equation. That reporter may still need to convince an editor or producer that the story deserves airtime, column inches or homepage placement.

​

Then the news cycle can change everything.

​

A major earnings surprise, a corporate scandal, a policy announcement or an unexpected breaking story can turn your million-dollar story into a ten-dollar one.

​

So, a story that might have led a newscast one day may not even make the cut the next.

​

That doesn’t necessarily mean your pitch wasn’t good. It may simply mean something else was more compelling at that moment.

 

This is one of the hardest truths about earned media. You can have a legitimate story, a well-crafted pitch and the right target, yet still miss your window, because timing and context matter as much as the idea.

​

When a pitch doesn’t land, the right question isn’t always, “What’s wrong with this story?” Sometimes it’s, “What’s competing with this story right now?”

​

That distinction matters. It can help PR teams decide whether to sharpen the pitch, find a different angle, approach another outlet or wait for a better moment.

​

You can’t control the news cycle. But understanding how newsrooms make decisions can help you navigate it.

​

Want to elevate your team’s media outreach?

​

Few communications teams and PR firms have ever had an inside look at how newsrooms operate.

​

Through my Media Reality Workshops, I pull back the curtain on how newsroom decisions are made, deconstruct and reframe your pitches through a veteran producer’s lens and help you align outreach with how journalists evaluate stories and prioritize coverage.

​

Get in touch to bring a newsroom perspective to your media strategy.